503 Comments

This might be possibly the most cynical thing I will write this week.

Consider the possibility that the GOP, the Heritage Foundation, the Federalist Society, etc. have all noticed Trump's increasing dementia and are all agreed upon it. They also all recognize that Trump is still their "big ticket item" for getting GOP turnout, and that without him the Republicans will not galvanize their base and get the voter turnout that they need to win in November. They are using Trump as their spearpoint for project 2025, and are fully prepared to invoke the 25th amendment once he gets into office. Once they have captured the government, they don't need him anymore.

Expand full comment

I don't think it is cynical so much as it is a rational explanation for what is happening in terms of his "support." I love that John Gartner is doing this. I appreciate it from the bottom of my heart. I think it's very important.

But a lot of us can see what is going on with Trump's brain. It is incredibly obvious to non-experts, so that means it is obvious to the people working on efforts like Project 2025 to take over the government. It's a great answer to the "why" Republicans helping him. It's not that they're "blind." They are perfectly content with his madness.

Expand full comment

Charles, I had the same thought as you and Douglas and it makes me ponder who might be the Republican VP candidate. If left entirely to Trump, that person could believably be a “Yes” person to all of Trump’s ideas and demands. Alternatively, a team of advisors serving as a VP search and vetting committee could conceivably suggest a name that they could sell to Trump but in reality be the person the backers of Project 2025 feel comfortable with assuming the office of president when Trump is sidelined by the 25th Amendment. If a search and vetting committee is formed, we will need to see who are the key players on that committee, as it could be likely, the VP suggested could be one of them and pre-determined from the start. That’s how Cheney picked himself to be GWB’s VP.

Expand full comment

Yep, that's why I downloaded the Project 2025 PDF document. I haven't read most of it yet. But it is chock full of names of the people responsible for it so that when Biden wins, we can take go all out Jacobin on them (no guillotines, just prison for the those who colluded with Russia).

Expand full comment

No guillotine? Even with a name like "Bastille?"

Expand full comment

Pen name. Happens to be my birthday, and sometimes my writing is even subversive enough to justify it. But I'm a pacifist so it all falls apart there.

Expand full comment

There can be a peaceful revolution. He simply #GeneralStrike #OccupyEverything #NoCompromise.

Punishing the despotic totalitarian criminals is a completely different matter.

Expand full comment

No. Heads on pikes. The taxpayers should not have to feed and house those bastards. It’s not about punishment anyway it’s about accountability. Do the right thing, either guillotine or heads on pikes lining the mall from the Lincoln Memorial to the Capitol steps and this shit won’t go down for 1000 years. Entire government have lost their heads for what we consent to every week. Rightly so!

Study policy, bro.

Expand full comment

I'm more of the feeling that we should put the entire lot of them out at Alcatraz and airdrop supplies to them. If they eat, they eat. If they can clean the place, they clean the place. If the plumbing works, great, but if not, oh, well. It's high time these entitled folks learned how the rest of us live. Think of it as a sociological experiment. How long can a bunch of highly self-centered, ego driven people survive on their own before they realize that society has to be INTER-dependent and that walking over others does not guarantee your survival in the long run. Many of them are "survivalists" with elaborate bunkers and think they can survive a nuclear holocaust. Great. Let them put those "skills" to use sans the bunkers. I'd bet those idiots can't make tea.

Expand full comment

I like your thinking.

Expand full comment

I'd like to know these names. About the only one I've heard so far is Stephen Miller.

Expand full comment
deletedApr 15·edited Apr 15
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

As an anti-Semite, you are obviously aware that Trump's son-in-law is an Orthodox Jew. Doesn't that just make your skin crawl? $45's grandkids are Jewish. I know that makes him cringe when he plays Papaw. Also, notice none of $45's family besides Lara is present in his courtroom or rallies.

Expand full comment
deletedApr 20
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

Trolling.

Expand full comment

I was thinking that.

Expand full comment

That’s exactly what will happen or is happening.

Expand full comment

That's treading too close to murky Rightwing waters...

They need to go to a secluded dark place for a very long time.

If we do Our absolute worst, they will retaliate with the same, probably on unarmed citizens. Like cowards do.

Expand full comment

If they do, they will be wiped out to the last person. Check your Russian agitprop bullshit Putin cocksleeve nonsense out of here. I’m not having it

Expand full comment

frightening!!

Expand full comment

In that case, in looking for their choice for VP, we'd probably be looking at the most devious but perhaps unassuming. Vance, Cotton & Carlson would probably be the more obvious popular choices among these people, but I wonder if someone like Tulsi Gabbard, Byron Donalds or Ben Carson might win out by appearing less threatening than they are & possibly appealing to constituencies they might not otherwise get.

Expand full comment

I happen to know that Reagan was cognitively impaired during his presidency (I worked in the Federal government at the time and had direct contact with “for the President’s eyes only” briefs)—but most of the public was kept unaware. So the GOP has been down this road before

Expand full comment

While they may have been down this road before, Reagan wasn't a dangerous, chaotic narcissist. They are not going to be able to control trump, hell they can't control him now.

Expand full comment
deletedApr 15
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

You seem to repeat your hatred here. Have you been cognitively tested for dementia? If not, you might consider it.

Expand full comment
deletedApr 20
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

Reagan, as misguided as he was, was genuinely concerned about the fate of the world and the country (he was, for example, said to have been deeply moved by the Jason Robards movie, "The Day After." I would argue there's a big difference between putting a shield around someone like that, and covering for a sociopath.

Expand full comment

He might have cared about the parts of the country who weren't dying of AIDS.

Expand full comment

He was a misguided soul, but what I thought I was saying was that he was interested in the direction of the country (and very prejudiced against a lot of different groups of people).

Expand full comment

Google "Operation Able Archer." In the fall of 1983 Ronald Reagan brought us closer to World War III than at any other time in history. I was living and working in West Germany at the time. "The Day After" came out after that, and scared the crap out of him.

Expand full comment

That’s a completely illegitimate take, if ever seen one. He was a self-serving convenient idiot.

Expand full comment

How was he convenient? And to whom? That sounds like something I'd read on a bad Twitter feed.

Expand full comment

He was quite convenient to the industrial military complex as is Biden. He’s the first person in the history of legal tender to spend $1 trillion defending us from a sovereign that was imploding of its own weight. Also, he was nothing more than a puppet for his Criminal advisers and lifelong large scale grifters. You are aware there was a Backchannel deal made with the Iranians about the hostages long before the election right? He was certainly convenient to the donor class being the first President of the United States to openly implement fascism. Being the corporate control of government on a department level. He was convenient for the fossil fuel entities.

Basically, he was convenient for the entire donor class because he had experience standing in front of a camera and saying nonsense. He just had to do it without a chimp.

He started this entire train rolling towards totalitarian despotism. Do you remember who was part of that unelected shadowy unannounced staff members assistance of assistance?

Roger Stone, Manafort, Ari Fleischer

HELLO

Expand full comment

Definitely. But I think Reagan's training as an actor helped him keep it together better. And while I don't really have much good to say about Nancy Reagan, she did love him and she shielded him and the world from his decline pretty well.

Expand full comment

Don’t forget, the rumor around Hollywood during that area was, she had no gag reflex…….

Expand full comment

I'd forgotten about all those rumors!

Expand full comment

That’s on “we the people” as this is entire debacle is. The electric chose a scene I’ll be right after who ruined the California economy just recently over a man with calluses on his hands and had placed his peanut Farm in a blind trust. Let me say that again,

placed his peanut Farm in a blind trust.

“We the people” are the government. We are beyond derelict in our duty.

There was only one caveat issued to the citizenry from the framers. We couldn’t even do that one single thing. “A Well informed and educated electorate”

whomever labeled us a “confederacy of dunces” overestimated us. We are straight up Dumbphukistan.

Expand full comment

Hey! Donald Trump has joined the conversation.

Beep, Boop, Boom. Waggle wiggle. Fromme

Expand full comment

Nebulous bullshit is all you’ve got? Really really fucked up stupid nebulous bullshit, even.

If bloody ever sees your work, your address will be BFE, Siberia forever

Expand full comment

You can't tell which way the train went by looking at the tracks ...

Expand full comment

Andy Borowitz's "Profiles in Ignorance" paints a pretty scary portrait of Reagan.

Expand full comment

Genocide joe cant be the one we vote for either, so niether

Expand full comment

Genocide Trump ordered his House lackies to help Putin by blocking Ukraine defense aid. He would simply let his bestie, Netanyahu flatten Gaza. At least Biden has a limit to his support of Netanyahu's offensive against Hamas, and has been pushing to get needed aid to the Palestinians.

Expand full comment

You are suffering from the illusion of choice fear demand big and dark money be removed from politik and the barriers to access the ballot the same. That is the only pass to restore the Republic.

Expand full comment

Don't vote for Biden then get Trump. Vacation in a relocation camp while enjoying your purity of non voting.

Expand full comment

Lying Trump Putin GOP agitprop cocksleeve is it terrible optic. No wonder your mother is so disappointed

Expand full comment

Then who?

Expand full comment

Very sad but sure seems to be the case. In my mind he has always been a deeply insecure and disturbed person. I think we see the exaggeration of these traits in his declining cognitive ability.

Expand full comment

The value in this article is that most of us refuse to listen to Trump anymore, so to have a compilation of his slurpy talk and cottage cheese thinking is invaluable. This attention to his slip and slide into dementia must keep coming, God forbid that President Biden decides to debate this mushroom!

Expand full comment

Oh, I'm most definitely not arguing against the value of the article. My point was that if people like me, with no psych qualifications other than my common sense, notice Trump's decline, the people who are closer to him and interact with him much more frequently than I do (I can't watch more than a minute of him without wanting to throw something), are fully aware of his decline.

Expand full comment

I believe the Trump campaign is already trying to reduce his live speaking events and move toward taped, and edited I'm sure, as quickly as possible. But there will likely those off the cuff pre and post court live rants.

Expand full comment

The big elephant in the room is, will they let him debate? That will be a disaster for him unless he has a "good day." People who've been around dementia know what I mean by that, but it's not a predictable occurrence.

Expand full comment

I think there’s going to be plenty of evidence of TFG’s decline during the trial. Court is exhausting, generally. I can only imagine how much stress TFG will be under, simply trying to pay attention, or at least look like he is.

Then when court recesses, he’ll go bonkers on TS. The timing will be optimal for seeing evidence of sundowning.

Expand full comment

A debate would be an excellent showcase of TFG’s declining cognitive function. And for precisely that reason, I’ll be awfully surprised if it ever happens!

Expand full comment

If he does, we can give him a wattle and a lollipop to suck on.

Expand full comment

The Heritage Foundation and Federalist Society power players behind Project 2025 and oligarch donor money are the ultimate controllers of Speaker Johnson and The Party of Putin in Congress as Trump becomes more of a Weekend at Bernie’s standup straw figurehead sinking into dementia.

If Trump’s decline is obvious to us, as painful as it is to endure more than ninety seconds of seeing and hearing him, as others have stated here it’s obvious to those in politics around him and logically accounts for limited public appearances and sheltering at Mar-a-Lago. But there will be no stating the emperor has no clothes as long as the Project 2025 masters are behind the curtain controlling all.

They probably won’t let him debate and although there is the possibility of an off cue one off impromptu inside of or leaving the courtroom, defendants needn’t say much unless directly required to reply to the judge. So don’t look for many sound bites there.

But how is Trump in a normal one to one conversation, away from cameras and crowds? British foreign secretary David Cameron visited Trump this week. As far as we know, Cameron is not beholden to Putin or Project 2025. We can only hope someone in the British press asks.

Expand full comment

Charles, you may be interested in this group hoping to Stop The Coup 2025: https://www.stopthecoup2025.org/

Expand full comment

I loved the visual chart of Leonard Leo!

Expand full comment

Thank you!

Expand full comment

I repeat, be where the VP pick

Expand full comment

Please provide examples of Trump actions that demonstrate his loss of metal acuity..

Expand full comment

The original article is chock full of them. Did you read it?

Expand full comment

I read all of it..like so much of this propaganda it provides no references to specific speeches or events..Biden cannot speak coherently without a teleprompter..

Expand full comment

You should stay on Truth Social where you won't be mocked for your cult membership.

Expand full comment

"Biden cannot speak coherently"

"No U!" stopped being a good comeback in second grade, Duggles.

The article that you insist that you read ALSO provides a thorough explanation of the difference between President Biden's normal aging and Trump's cognitive decline.

Expand full comment

Second grade and you other post put in in the category of blocked..

Expand full comment

Uncle Bosey eaten by cannibals and other strange mumblings of Biden...Biden cannot speak without cue cards..when was his last press conference with open questions?? Biden will not do a debate. It would not be possible for him..Trump speaks all of the time without que cards and is capable of debating...forget either flawed candidate...vote for the best candidate..see JFK jr..he has a real chance.

Expand full comment

It’s full of comms. Trump provides breadcrumbs and comms but unless you are really diligently seeking the truth, You just don’t understand his skills of playing chess on a 5D level. If you’re ever interested in doing your own research in your own discernment, go to Rumble follow badlands media. Listen to eye of the storm follow SGT report. Listen to some of the stuff find the truth go research it then come back and say that Trump is declining. Everything he says is for a reason just like when he said Pelosi and Nikki it was to get the news papers, the news stations, the reporters to all say that Pelosi was the one in charge of January 6, because no one would say it was a happy day for us , and make it sound like he’s losing his mind. There are so many things in this article that I could explain in detail as to what he was referring to. When he makes comms, he hast to stretch out the words he hast to do something or say it in a way for it to be picked up on . Taken to the Q and decoded. You can like my reply or not, but if you’re this far and deep into things, why not due to a little bit more research. Why not want to know so many people realize what he and the white hats are doing for this country and he has saved our lives and is continuing to. Learn about Biden and the things that he has done. Biden beat Obama because Obama was bad but Biden is far worse. In so many evil evil corrupt ways they couldn’t give it to you all at once. It’s being unveiled slowly in the meantime you guys think that Trump is getting hit with all these indictments and stuff when it’s a showcase where our country has gone and how our rights have been stripped away and how unfair, the political system and the governmental system is. It’s to teach us what our rights are. Half of the people in the world can’t name the three branches of government. This is all been done slowly in order to show people what has been going on behind the scenes and Biden is a puppet. He’s a puppet of the ministration, but he beats Obama hand down when it comes to what he was doing to us Americans. And I do say was as in past tense and I firmly believe that. Just do yourself a favor a little further do a little more research. You’ll learn that everything Trump does for a reason. He’s way up there playing chess and you guys are way down here , not knowing what’s going on because you haven’t dug deep enough or maybe you just don’t really wanna believe that the q movement was all for a reason.

Expand full comment

Come back when you learn how to make paragraphs, pookie. Of course, that's the third grade, so the election will long be over by the time you get there.

Expand full comment

You expect me to read your mess with no paragraphing and improper punctuation. I just randomly read 2 or 3 sentences. They were so bad and ungrammatical that I stopped reading.

Expand full comment

Are comms comments?

Expand full comment

I don't know Jeanne. Maybe he means communists. ???

Expand full comment

You are in a cult. You have detached from reality if you believe a single word you typed. On the other hand, it was comical reading, so maybe you were being sarcastic?

Expand full comment

You need to go back to school.

Expand full comment

Who are you addressing your request to? The author of the article? He lists literally dozens of examples, and goes into specific detail as to exactly why and how the examples he lists are problematic.

Maybe read it?

Expand full comment

I would recommend reading DM's comment (if you have a strong stomach) to get a full glimpse of what we are up against. To put it kindly, there are people who belong in straight jackets who will be voting in November.

Expand full comment

I did and I was gobsmacked. I think DM may be in the throes of dementia as well. Several words were simply unnecessarily abbreviated or simply made up. The amount of tangential misinformation and the level of narrative incoherence is frightening.

Expand full comment

But it got us to "gobsmacked," which is one of my favorite words. :-)

Expand full comment

Marissa, I give you great credit for having the stomach and fortitude to read DM's crazy comment. I couldn't do it!

Expand full comment

Unfortunately, they also breed.

Expand full comment

Who's DM?

Expand full comment

Look up the thread a bit. Or search the page using your browser's Find tool for "It’s full of comms"

Expand full comment

Yes..dozens examples with no references..also most are trivial. Biden is far worse off mentally than Trump.the author is bias. Neither is a great choice.

Expand full comment

Doug: "Give me an example."

Half a dozen commenters in this thread: "500 psychologists with expertise and experience gave examples in the article. That was LITERALLY the point of the article."

Doug: "No, not like that."

Expand full comment

The article would have been 4x longer if exact speech locations were provided. You should try google, if you want video proof. It works! (Everyone else reading has seen the videos, heard the gaffes, witnessed the decline in speech and cognition. Sorry for your inability to process reality.)

Expand full comment

The article is not balanced..Biden has dementia and is a very forgetful old man...uncle bosey eaten by canibles..etc..He will not do a debate and cannot speak coherently without cue cards. Forget either flawed candidate vote JFK jr. He has a real chance..

Expand full comment

Injecting bleach and shoving a full spectrum high UV light device up your ass did it for me…..

Expand full comment

And genocide joe is an ok guy?

Expand full comment

The term "genocide joe" is used by people who don't understand foreign relations, and sometimes by paid Putin trolls. Where is your outrage over Netanyahu? Do you have any familiarity at all with Israeli politics or why Israel is where it is? Have you expressed your outrage at Israelis consistently electing far-right ethnic cleansers into office during the last thirty years? Are you even aware of it?

The "genocide joe" lunkheads also ignore that Trump enabled Netanyahu's behavior BY MOVING THE AMERICAN EMBASSY TO JERUSALEM, which should be an open city for all religions.

Ignorance is inexcusable in a situation like Gaza. Read. Stop looking at TikTok videos from Putin's Internet Research Agency.

Expand full comment

How many more times will you repeat this? It's stale already, but somehow I don't think you're capable of cogent debate.

Expand full comment
Apr 11·edited Apr 11

I spent from 2015 to June of 2023 watching Alzheimer's take my father. These symptoms djt is exhibiting remind me of 3-4 years ago with Pop, especially the confabulation and speech issues. My father was an engineer by trade and watching the lost ability to figure things out was devastating. The decline is steadily subtle at first and then all at once, it's exponential. I don't think what you are saying is cynical at all. I've always felt that man is just a means to an end for a much darker group.

Expand full comment

I feel for what you went through, it's truly devastating. I am watching stroke related dementia take my mother. She doesn't have the memory issues seen in Alzheimer's patients but her cognitive decline is apparent. But because she can pass the standard "dementia test"- she knows day, month, president and "why she is here" answers- I can't get a diagnosis from a doctor. Her decline is in the more exponential state now and yet most times she makes more sense than TFG.

Expand full comment

Vascular dementia took my aunt, and it took forever to get a diagnosis—please keep looking for doctors, and I am so sorry. ♥️

Expand full comment

Thank you!

Such a horrible thing to watch someone you love become someone they aren't.

Expand full comment

Watched a dear friend go through that one. He was a medical professional and had to give it up. His dear wife is truly a warrior as he's now in his 9th year of this.

Expand full comment

I’m so very sorry. 😔

Expand full comment

My mom had, it turned out, lesions on her brain due to Korsakoff’s Syndrome, a kind of dementia, the result of her being a decades-long alcoholic. She could easy “pass” at first when being examined, which why it was important for a family member to accompany her to & sit in on exams. After extended/multiple interactions most medicos finally “got it” & it opened the door to more appropriate diagnosis, treatment & referrals. She ended up in a locked facility after wandering away from a nursing home once (she was found sitting in a car of the hospital across the street—she tried all the doors and got in the first unlocked vehicle thinking they could drive her home), and an unlocked assisted living facility twice (police found her wandering the nearby streets) —this last place finally said “get her out of here, we can’t be responsible for her any longer”.

Expand full comment

Thanks so much. It's a beast. Frankly, we are still recovering from that last year with it all.

Expand full comment

Recovery takes a long time and some forgiveness to yourself for the times you lost patience or wanted to just run away from it all. Know you are not alone. Find humor in memory of the really absurd moments.

Expand full comment

I share a similar experience and your current concern.

Expand full comment

I was going to write something even more cynical, that Republicans, even moderates like Romney and Cheney, will leave him in place (because they are scared of his followers). They believe they can use him like a puppet. They'll just prop him up on some pillows with a hamburger and keep on going.

The enablers in his first term assumed they could control him. They could not then, they cannot now. So, the Jamie Dimon, Elon Musk, and other billionaires who are funding Trump once again are fooling themselves--once again. They'll think the dementia will make him manageable. So much for our brilliant tech and financial geniuses.

Only this time Trump will have his finger on the nuclear weapons and will be inviting Putin to throw anyone who crosses him out the window.

Expand full comment

Yes and no. They definitely will prop him up with pillows and possibly make a fake Oval Office for him to hang out in. The VP and others will do the real presidenting.

He won't be more manageable but they will pump him up with tranquilizers to make him easier to deal with. He won't be doing foreign trips. He won't be interacting with world leaders. He'll have some excuse the will keep him home.

His handlers will not let him near the nuclear weapons.

Expand full comment

Yep, I can see that happening. Totally plausible. The madness is not just Trump, it's his even more insane and greedy enablers.

Expand full comment

Although, I don't think they'll be able to control his access to anything, including nuclear weapons, war, and so on, so forth. Remember, he's got his buddy Putin to throw people out of windows for him, keep everyone in line. The real puppeteer will be Putin in the end.

Expand full comment

Everyone is distracted by the 'smokescreen' of the 'court room soap opera' . . . . With an immense amount of discussion about all the reasons why it is unthinkable that Trump could be reelected, I still do not hear any mention of the 'ultimate DEAL BREAKER" . . . . This is it . . . . Imagine this man 'in charge of two thousand million tons of thermo nuclear weapons again?' . . . . And General Milley won't be there to stop him this time ! . . . . . End of discussion ! . . . . . gasp

Expand full comment

You’re absolutely right. It’s an appalling prospect, not to mention surreally Orwellian.

Expand full comment

His dementia is really progressing now. He won't know where he is.

Expand full comment

EDIT - they may just use Amendment 25 and remove him in favor of his VP. I'm guessing that the Federalist Society or the Heritage Foundation will be picking his VP - someone they can work with. It'll be someone super far right but competent and yet not electable on his own. They will offer him a deal to be president.

Expand full comment

That would be so Machiavellian it would put Machiavelli to shame.

Expand full comment

Considering how they bought SCOTUS judges, it's what I expect of them.

Expand full comment

I think he will pick Haley because of her constituency, and because his well-heeled donors will want someone they can slide by the voters as 'moderate' when she really isn't. She just showed up in Israel to pick at Biden yesterday. Very concerning.

Expand full comment

But she said some mean things about him and got way too many votes for her to be a safe pick. He's looking for another Pence. I don't think he thinks that Haley will be loyal. She'll pull Amendment 25 as soon as she can.

Expand full comment

Edith Wilson, Woodrow’s wife, was effectively running the government following her husband’s severe stroke while she kept his condition from the public and all but his closest team members.

Expand full comment

Putin would love to have Melania running things but she doesn't want to work.

I'm very familiar with the Edith Wilson story. She did a pretty good job at it.

Expand full comment

Yep

Expand full comment

Imagine a world where Romney and Cheney are moderate? Ho Lee Phuk

Expand full comment

I've been thinking the same thing. He's just a tool to them.

Expand full comment

Somewhat like Reagan.

Expand full comment

I remember an old saying that I believe to be true - "When it comes to money and politics, no matter how cynical you are - it isn't cynical enough".

Expand full comment

I have been considering this possibility since that appears to have happened under Reagan as well once he had dementia. It was hidden and the people around him just went right on governing, I presume aided by Nancy Reagan. Since I, a stranger have figured out that he appears to have dementia although I did not know the causes, drugs, or aging alone, and that he had aphasia, and wondered whether he has had a stroke, I can imagine that people around him must really notice the things going on with him. Jeff Tiedrich in his Substack reports tirelessly about the ways in which Donald Trump's mental and physical faculties are slipping, with videos so one can hear his speech and see his mannerisms. It becomes so obvious even from small clips. https://substack.com/@jefftiedrich

So, we need to have an alternative plan to the Right Wing Fascists nefarious doings. This is the Nazi Party developing all over again. I call these groups and politicians The New American Nazi Party, because Nazis is the most apt description for the Republican Party under Trump and those who support it.

Expand full comment

Cynical? I would say more like reality. What is the best way for the elite to protect and insulate themselves from the masses? Get the masses to fight among themselves. How does a leader unite the people behind him? Go to war against a perceived enemy.

It is all psychology that is out there, researched, published and understood.

Trump IS NOT the elites hero. He is their puppet.

However, sometimes the puppet develops a mind of its own and goes off the deep end.

There is a historical precedent. However, before I tell it, there are many who highly dispute this history but, as you will see, they have very strong reasons to dispute this story that has nothing to do with the truth.

In the Persian world before ISLAM, the religion was Zorasterism. With any religion, different groups think differently and seek power for their beliefs. One such group were the astrologer-priests called the Magi. These were supposedly the three wise men at the manger.

This Magi group was not in power but they came up with a plan. They needed an easily influenced person, not too bright, to be their spear to go to war against their enemies in Persia. Somebody similar to Trump. They found their guy, and spent a lot of time convincing this guy he was hearing the voices of angels giving him the word of god. Of course, these Magi write down these revelations as their guy was illiterate.

They created a new religion that was a spear to attack their enemies. However, these Wise Men did not know about the butterfly effect from chaos theory and this religion not only conquered their enemies but, also, conquered them.

The oligarchs in Russia helped put a guy in charge to control the masses and protect their fortunes. Now Putin can kill them. This in what happens when one creates a Frankenstein monster.

So hopefully people will understand that Trump and his court jesters at Fox Noise are all tools. When this election is over, if Trump defeated, focus needs to be in the direction of the real enemies of this country, preventing it from evolving towards an ideal—ideals do not really exist except in the mind of Plato and those he influenced—of a country that we were all lied to and told we already were.

Hopefully, then we as a people can start dealing with our original sin and our other sins.

Expand full comment

Douglas Brown - further to this - I completely agree with your speculations, and find them not at all cynical. it’s my contention that the choice of VP to Trump is of vital importance - his “handlers” fully intend to replace him in fairly short order after he’s sworn in. In fact, it’s not inconceivable that they’ll bypass the succession altogether and go straight to something like a ruling junta. If not replaced by a 25th Amendment invocation, a highly visible and public assassination would have the dual value of ridding them of Trump, and galvanizing the base in anger against the “libs.”

And as I say these things, I recognize how “conspiracy theory “ based they are. It’s all speculation, but it’s based on observable phenomena. What is virtually certain, however, is that Trump is not in control either of himself, or his campaign and possible future presidency. I keep hoping I’m wrong, but I can’t convince myself that I am.

Expand full comment

That will backfire if they try it. Trump's 2nd term will be about putting himself beyond anyone's control. He is going to install only people who will defend him, whether or not P2025 planners like them. Theofascists can prepare a throne for their planned king, but if Trump doesn't like it he'll have acolytes ready to deal with the situation. Trump is planning a dynasty.

Expand full comment

Dennis McD, I can’t agree. Trump is literally controlling nothing now - he’s being permitted to think he is, because it’s useful to the Flynns and Millers and Bannons and many more who we don’t know about. This is not, perhaps never was about Trump.

Expand full comment

I think this is exactly what will happen. He is their useful idiot.

Expand full comment

We will see what VP nominee the Heritage FOundtion and Federlisst Socity will choose to be tRump's running mate. If, by some deep obscenity of historic turn, tRump wins the presidency, those organizations will throw him under the bus by Amendment 25 and complete their coup d'état. This, of course, would require that those nefarious organizations also appoint the cabinet for tRump. (Getting them confirmed by a rEpublicrite senate will be child's play.)

Expand full comment

Their big input will be into who they choose for his VP. That's the person they are going to use to get things done. It won't be trump's choice, he's not the money guys.

Expand full comment

No doubt, this is what is going on.

Expand full comment

i absolutely believe this is true.

but i am more worried that T$#@% won't make it to the gen election and that a shiny, articulate, younger, Project 25 adherent will take his place and the GOP mods now planning to vote for Biden to avoid T$%#$ will return to the GOP.

we have to foreground Project 25.

Expand full comment

I absolutely agree. We cannot let ANY Republican win the White House in this contest.

Expand full comment

MY EXACT THOUGHTS. After all the GOP has a history of finding this sort of President (ignorant puppet) VERY useful in the past: i.e. Reagan & GW Bush...not to mention easily manipulated Trump in his previous term....

Expand full comment

Wow! You’ve made a good point!

Expand full comment
Apr 11Liked by Jay Kuo, The Big Picture, George Takei

One small correction, the former guy DOES NOT HAVE AN MBA. He attended the undergraduate business school at UPenn, which also known as Wharton. He did not attend the Wharton graduate program.

Expand full comment
author

We have corrected this reference. Thank you.

Expand full comment

I noticed that you simply stated he “attended” undergraduate school…

😉

Expand full comment

Obvious due to his exceptional business acumen. Facetious comment intended.

Expand full comment

And he paid someone to take his entrance exams

Expand full comment

I think more than just his entrance exams!

Expand full comment

Rumored to be his sister, the eventual judge …

Expand full comment

I want to say that I had heard she had done his work for him, but I'm not sure if it was earlier or later.

Expand full comment

They’re making huge strides. KenStarr spent 90 billion bucks on a blow job and Trump has whittle it down immensely.

Expand full comment

While 1 of his professors said he was the blankety blank dumbest student he'd ever had, so he may have Bought his graduation grades. Like everything else.

Expand full comment

Really glad to hear that,my dear friend.Don't make Trump sound better than what he truly is.And may God in the nmae of Decency kindly Stop Trump & his MAGA Creeps very ,very Soon!

Expand full comment

Soon after he became president I decided I needed to watch him give a speech, hoping to understand his plans as president and his thought process better. After about ten minutes I understood all I needed. He couldn't finish a thought or even many sentences. I really had no idea what his message was. And this was in 2017.

I believe people do have a duty to warn. Thank you for this article.

Expand full comment

Exactly, this. I doubt I've watched him for more than 5 full minutes at one sitting. He's been incoherent for a long time.

Expand full comment

Consider words like ‘hamberder’ and ‘confefe’. He used both during his term in office. Four years later, he is visibly declining.

Expand full comment

'confefe' launched a million memes, lol. Wasn't that originally in a tweet?

Expand full comment

Yes, in fact it was the tweet. Just that one ‘word’

Expand full comment

“Covfefe” launched a thousand online comedians.

Expand full comment

And there were reasons for it. Play five D chess onTrump‘s level and the white hats levels so that you can discern the comms.

Expand full comment

He’s not declining, he’s providing more comms. That’s the problem. You guys give him five minutes, but you don’t spend five hours doing some research to discern the truth. Be fiction. If anyone is declining, it would be Biden if you were even here probably.

Expand full comment

You keep telling yourself that, sweety. Good Luck.

Expand full comment

Wake up. T’s thought processes are a rambling, incoherent mess. You must be deaf & blind.🙉🙈😳

Expand full comment

Could not agree more.

Expand full comment
author

Correction: This article originally referred to Trump an "Ivy League MBA.” We have corrected it to read "Ivy League graduate,” as his degree from Wharton degree was an undergraduate degree.

Expand full comment

What concerns me more than Trumps mental illness is the American vulnerability/inclination to be attracted to authoritarianism. Authoritarian personality traits are strong in 35 percent of the American population. Scholars like Jonathan Weiler and Matthew MacWilliams have found that ONLY about 25 per cent of the American population are on the non-authoritarian end of the spectrum.35 per cent are somewhere in the middle and 30-35 per cent are on the authoritarian end of the scale. That’s the bigger picture that keeps Trump so much in the picture and leaves so much left out of the picture and that keeps our debates so narrowly framed.

Balanced inclusive deliberative thinking is replaced with shortcuts, stereotypes with strong men with simple solutions. The fragmentation of social media and politics has the space for thoughtful discussion becoming smaller and smaller as we go faster and faster with increasing volumes of algorithmic information. The loudest unbalanced voice gets rewarded with the most attention in our attention economy. In our winner takes all society bullies win.

Expand full comment

Yikes! We have work to do to come to another conclusion. We shouldn’t let bullies win!!

Expand full comment

This makes me feel that I’ve lived in a different universe my 83 years. I’ve always had a real faith in American democracy. Kennedy’s assassination opened my eyes to another reality, but didn’t really dim that faith. I believed in the election system, until W. Had hope again with Obama, until arrival of Trump. It’s like a film was lifted from my eyes and ears. I’ve become rabid, even as my physical abilities begin diminishing. The Heritage Foundation and Project 25 is absolutely terrifying. I feel we now know the real enemy and need to proceed with great strength and every source at hand to defeat them. I’m certainly hoping this current court case is going to add speed to Trump’s cognitive decline and make it impossible for him to be the real presidential candidate. How’s that for wishful thinking? Gartner’s group of mental health experts need greater recognition and voice.

Expand full comment

A lot of tfg’s supporters are people scared for their future. Not excusing that they’re propping up a wannabe dictator; just saying that they begin “othering” the unknown and directing mayhem toward those others. Which feeds into the takeover plans of oligarchs like Jamie Dimon, Elon Musk, Koch, etc. Researchers have found that a huge portion of those inclined to support tfg are prototypically the least educated among us. Which is why we must defend and improve public education.

Expand full comment

I’ve given some thought to that too—the attraction

to authoritarianism. I think many of them have been brainwashed—seriously. And/or it’s a fad. And/or for whatever reason, they think they know what it is but have no real idea, just like most Americans have no

clue how our government works. If Trump is elected

I fully expect a chaotic, grifting free for all among the Cabinet members. Steve (new world order after we burn it all down) Bannon and Stephen (put kids in cages) Miller will fight each other over which of them

gets to torture political rivals and they’ll probably end up pushing them out of high rise windows,

emulating their role model Putin.

Expand full comment

Lack of independent thinking skills, lack of knowledge-understanding of how government works-civics-the speed and volume of misinformation-the ease of and addiction to social media, a tool that needs to be used wisely rather than mindlessly to group think and organize around conspiracy theories ... lack of thinking skills with lots of INSECURITY- fears, And insecure facts on the ground-the grotesque inequality in America all add up to resentments and seeking revenge with simple solutions. If you look at the research, it's not just Republicans that are inclined towards authoritarianism. In 1941 Eric Fromm wrote Escape From Freedom. That escape happens even in our most liberal of universities.... Schools of thought can become-have become cults.

Expand full comment

Thanks for such a detailed account of his madness. I like to refer people to his radio interviews with Howard Stern. If you listen to them, you hear a guy who is clearly a jerk, but he's a jerk who can string paragraphs together and stay on point. This is no longer the case at all.

I'm sure Mr. Gartner is correct. He'll be a vegetable before his term is up. I thought he would be by now, based on his previous term, but he's hung in there somehow. I have witnessed dementia up close and personal. I don't like using the word, "vegetable," to refer to someone who is suffering, but in his case, it is we who are suffering. He needs to be shut down, and I appreciate Mr. Gartner's efforts. I also relate to Mr. Gartner's not wanting to be involved with politics. I look forward to the day when I can ignore politics, too.

Expand full comment

His trial(s) might accelerate his decline...

Expand full comment

The stress of the civil suits clearly pushed him to the edge. His behavior in those courtrooms demonstrates that he lacks even the limited self-control that he once possessed, and he was only in court for a handful of days, apparently trying to intimidate witnesses during their testimony.

For the criminal trials, he will have to be at the defense table whenever the jury is present. I think it will be maddening for him. Perhaps his people will give him a mild tranquilizer each morning.

Expand full comment

Is that correct? . . . . Is he legally required to be present at his criminal trail? . . . .

Expand full comment

Yes. He has to be there. Or at least be logged into zoom to watch.

Expand full comment

Yes. During the rough periods of the pandemic (and sometimes now with lesser hearings), proceedings were/are done remotely. When it's considered safe, defendants in most cases must be in the courtroom when the jury is, unless the judge excuses them. That usually only happens for emergencies.

Technically, it's for the defendant's benefit. If they don't observe the proceedings, they can't have timely consultation with their attorney or judge the quality of the defense offered. Of course, it also allows the jury to see the defendant's behavior during the proceedings. Jurors are instructed to reach a verdict based solely on the evidence, but they're allowed to form an impression of the defendant's ... sincerity, I guess you can call it.

Expand full comment

Thank you.

Expand full comment

He made a statement recently after 1 of his Many recent court cases, that he would do more evening rallies. (for $donations$)

So that will put his sundowner symptoms, after a frustrating day in court, on full display to his supporters, if they even notice. Cameras need to be in full focus, liberal news needs to share what the right leaning media will hide from their public. Along with the Many obvious lists of dementia symptoms & possible diagnosis from the actual experts! Republicans have aging parents, too. Usually with lax Red state Healthcare to help...

Expand full comment

Right. Any of us who have been around the symptoms, and I think that's a lot of us on all parts of the political landscape, will recognize the various traits. If only a small percentage of his former voters become alarmed, maybe they'll at least sit out the election.

Expand full comment

Thank you (and the others who signed the document you cite) for your courage and thoroughness in summarizing all of this. Those of us who don't watch the rallies or speeches or read them, other than as passing references in the mainstream press - and all too rarely there - are able to parse together this clinical picture. When he was president, I did read the mainstream press, and was shocked at how each would edit his words so they made sense. I wondered then why they were doing that. In your post today, I also appreciate your reflection: "One day, in silence, in my garden, I felt the Universe, God, the Force, whatever you want to call it, communicate with me."

Expand full comment

ALL LAME-STREAM MEDIA IS CORRUPT.

Expand full comment
Apr 11Liked by Todd Beeton

Thank you for a very helpful and detailed coverage of an important issue. Sad that the mainstream media is so terrified of actually committing journalism that they won't ever consider covering the issue.

This likely helps explain why he is so terrified of a debate. Having to be on stage side-by-side with Prez. Biden would make it blindingly obvious to everyone watching just who the doddering "old man" was . . .

Expand full comment

“actually committing journalism” is a great way to say it! It’s sad that we can’t depend upon the media to tell the whole truth! If it weren’t for Substack writers I’d be lost!

Expand full comment

ALL LAME-STREAM MEDIA IS CORRUPT.

Expand full comment

"..the mainstream media is so afraid of commiting journalism that they won't even consider covering the issue.".

Is the best description of the situation I've heard.

Expand full comment
Apr 11Liked by Todd Beeton, The Big Picture

Excellent article and one that should be shared on all platforms. The American people need to know these warning signs.

Expand full comment

"If you can’t trust doctors, when we’re talking about a medical condition, then who can you trust?" This is yet another reason why Republicans have been anti-science. I'm also old enough to remember Ronald Reagan's second term where he appeared less and less often in public. It was later learned that he had dementia and others were actually running the country.

Expand full comment

This made me think of the second Reagan term as well. I don't think he was as far along in his decline as Trump clearly is, but he definitely had better handlers and he didn't start out as a narcissist, which makes Trump very dangerous indeed.

Expand full comment

I think his acting training helped him cope better. He could deliver his lines and his handlers could get him out of the room before any questions started.

Expand full comment
Apr 11Liked by Todd Beeton, The Big Picture

Thank you for being so clear with this important information. Some of us knew and saw the deterioration but did not have the professional, clinical words to talk about what we were seeing.

Expand full comment

He also misidentified E. Jean Carroll as his former wife and stays up all hours of the night posting on his fake twitter account. His makeup application lately has been especially egregious, reminding me of my 96 year old grandmother applying too much “rouge” and thinking it is beautiful.

These indicate sundowning, or maybe abusing some types of stimulants like Adderall. Some think he is using Ozempic to lose weight and this may be causing his dementia like symptoms, but that seems to be a cop out to me. I truly believe the signers of this document are precisely on point.

Expand full comment

The make-up! Where is that coming from?? Ever since his trials have begun, the makeup is like that “96 year old aunt” you mentioned. I didn’t understand why his “people” didn’t “fix it for him” but then remembered it’s Trump. No one can tell him anything - so they don’t cross him.

Expand full comment

Trying to fix my relative's make-up, clothing or check hearing aids meant getting slapped really hard.

Expand full comment

I'm waiting for him to add lipstick to his routine.

Expand full comment

Yep!! Girdle…check, hair extensions…check, shoe lifts….check, foundation makeup….check, lipstick!!!! which color goes with orange?

Expand full comment

This is one of the most terrifying articles I have ever read, it made my blood run cold. Dementia is awful, but a demented TRUMP in the WH would be a disaster for our country.

Expand full comment

Thanks to the 25th Amendment, Trump's VP pick may prove to be historic.

Expand full comment

That frightens me as well.

Expand full comment

It will be someone handpicked by the Heritage Foundation and The Federalist Society, someone who will aid them in the suspension of the Constitution and destruction of democracy, to be replaced by an authoritarian oligarchy.

Expand full comment

A hand picked non elected President,answering to his handlers only ! That is a frightening scenario, but a very possible one! The traitors in Congress will be tripping over each other to sign up for their slice of the new American Corporate Governance!

Expand full comment

That's what they're doing now with violating the Court's Gag Orders for Trump by dressing like him and mouthing off in front of the building. Little Trumpian Clones.

Expand full comment

Thank you! Many of us who've paid attention to this man have noticed these changes but did not have the medical expertise to define it. I do not believe Trump will be re-elected due to many other factors but he's too close to the oval office. It's likely to be a nail-biter election and there's much foul play afoot to cause confusion and mistrust.

Expand full comment

I think he won't be elected. He's going to get worse and only his cult will vote for him. He'll lose the people who aren't blinded.

Plus he's responsible for Dobbs and that is going to cut into quite a lot of votes.

A lot of families have used or will need to use IVF and then there are the women who have pregnancies go bad. That whole mishegoss is going to sink not only trump (who's proud of what he's done) but a lot of other Republicans as well.

Expand full comment

Two words - women and anamnesis.

I just hope you’re right that it’s enough to keep Pres. Biden in, and L’enfant Orange out, of office.

Expand full comment

I really hope you are right. But I don’t mind admitting that he scares me. Anyone who openly says he admires dictators scares me.

My dad was in the oil industry and I grew up under a dictator, in Venezuela, in the 1950s. We do NOT want that here!

Expand full comment

I hope I'm right as well! :D

The people that think they want him as a dictator are not factoring in what it really is to live under a dictator. They will not be safe.

Expand full comment

Personally, I ran out of nails some time ago.😬

Expand full comment

I noticed that Trump's only general public-facing presentations, (not his MAGA-loving rallies,) seem to be highly edited videos.

I wonder if he'll functionally collapse, and then all ANYBODY will see of him will be highly edited videos from Mar-a-lago.

Where's Waldo???

Expand full comment

Wouldn't they just use AI to make images of him and giving speeches? I'm not an expect by any means of this technology but could they use it to fool his foolish supporters into thinking he is ok? I'm sure if this were possible, they have people to implement this. Scary........

Expand full comment

I've considered this as well. I'm concerned AI videos will play a disturbing part this election cycle.

Expand full comment

Frighteningly I think you might be right about that possibility. What a world of illusion and mistrust and resultant chaos and division we seem to be upon the brink.

Expand full comment

He loved his rallies, but his people have realized that he can't keep it together for them.

But they may try switching to afternoon rallies while he's still fresh as the campaign gets going.

Expand full comment